Physicians are the Superheroes, NOT the Villains

Physicians are the Superheroes, NOT the Villains: A commentary on a NY Mag piece that vilifies physician


I heard a joke the other day. It was uttered by a physician who was frustrated at having spent 45 minutes of her free time getting approval for a necessary patient test.

She needed to vent. Her joke went something like this:


Q: Under your insurance plan, do all diagnostic procedures require pre-authorization?

A: No, only those you need.


(*Insert slapstick sound here*)


Is anyone laughing out loud right about now? Probably not. It’s cute, but it’s also cringe-worthy.

It’s hard to genuinely laugh when our health is involved. We expect our insurance company to cover all aspects of our health flawlessly, especially with what we pay to have it there in the first place.

Well, as a primary care physician I can tell you that the above example is just one of many examples in which insurance limits the way I practice. I won’t bore you with details of others. At least not in this post.



NY Mag Not in Agreement.


NY Magazine doesn’t seem to agree with me. Or with doctors in general. In fact, according to an article they published, we are the villains of healthcare.

Their piece, published on June 29, 2019, painfully rubbed salt into our already significant wounds. (I’m referring to a systemic burnout. A whopping 44% of physicians reported feeling burned out, in January 2019, according to a Medscape survey that circulate among our ranks).

The author, John Barro, named his piece “Democrats Obsess Over Health Insurance When They Should Fight Doctors and Hospitals.” You can read it here. He is, understandably, a journalist, and not a physician. I’m adding this to merely point out that he doesn’t actually work the front lines, as we do; a relevant fact, I think.



I Responded, a Gut Reaction.


This weekend, I crafted my response to his piece. I found the article to be appalling to my profession.

It simply got so much wrong.

After you read through it yourself, I’d appreciate your consideration on this:


1. Many doctors are in debt – the likes of several hundreds of thousands – when we finish our training. Finishing our training occurs around our 30’s. So do the math.


2. We’re getting lumped in with hospitals. What hospitals charge has little to do with physicians. We are separate entities, and are typically the ones who are merely cogs in the wheel. We’re the employed, doing the important work of healthcare. Ever consider the ratio of administrators to physicians? It’s 10-1. I’ll leave it at that, so you can do the math on this, too. Danielle Ofri touched on this, in her eloquent NYTimes article, which I’ll reference here.



Physicians are the Superheroes, NOT the Villains: A commentary on a NY Mag piece that vilifies physician



3. What lobbying? Doctors are underrepresent in any major decision-making organization in this country. We spend all our time healing. And we’re getting burned out because, among other things, of articles like this. They place blame in the wrong direction.


4. Physicians who take insurance only get to set the prices they ‘want’. In reality, they will receive what insurance contractually agreed upon, or ‘wants’.


5. We do ‘save lives’, as is stated in that last paragraph. Which is why we SHOULD be valued. We are crucial for the life-saving team (between patient and physician!). The other entities mentioned – the insurance companies, the pharmaceutical companies – these are merely extraneous players that have been inserted into the equation, over time, as middlemen. They have now become more powerful than ever, because of money, because of lobbying, and because of who’s ultimately ‘in control’. Because doctors are too busy saving lives to speak up for themselves. Would you want it any other way? Well, now we need to start speaking up.



Physicians are the Superheroes, NOT the Villains: A commentary on a NY Mag piece that vilifies physicians



6. Tort reform. Want to actually speak about a topic that will save us money? Allow physicians to practice as should be. Not defensively. Without excess testing. Allow us to put down our guard and be practice medicine as it’s meant to be. Tort reform is the real answer to saving money as a nation.


7. Calling us villains? Really? Will the younger generation seek out medicine as a profession if we continue to devalue physicians like this? Or will there realistically be less and less motivation to pursue a field that is constantly:

– blasted by media (as if we are an enemy of some sort)

– badmouthed in the form of public reviews, without the same freedoms as everyone else to respond (if you don’t know why, look up ‘HIPAA’)

– lobbied against, in order to tighten regulations to the point where we choke, not able to practice as medicine should be practiced; as an art.



Physicians are the Superheroes, NOT the Villains: A commentary on a NY Mag Piece that vilifies physicians



Lastly, some food for thought: Who’s really behind this piece?


Feel free to weigh in below. Positive or negative, all opinions welcome.



Pin me please:


Physicians are the Superheroes, NOT the Villains: A commentary on a NY Mag Piece that vilifies physicians

Share my work:

2 Responses

  1. Really well said.

    It is amazing what an individual has to endure to become a physician. You essentially put your life on hold. While others graduate college and get a job and start a family we still have to take on the student role and even worse incur more debt. The delay in earning money is also a time penalty as our debt grows while others can start saving and using compound interest for their benefit.

    Then when we finally start making money all the deductions everyone else enjoys gets phased out. Because of the progressive income tax structure we get taxed higher than anyone else even if we still have a negative net worth because of our growing debt.

    We are the easy target for lawyers, administrators, and politicians because they see our salary and just see dollar signs.

    Nevermind that in order to be physicians we are doing at the very least 1.5 FTE equivalent. It is funny when docs say they are cutting back on their clinical practice and still do over 40 hours a week.

    Nevermind that we give up time with family being on call or in house during holidays etc.

    That people looking to cut costs prefer hiring mid levels because it makes economic sense

  2. I wrote an article published on KevinMD and mr website. It is entitled: “Patients Expect Just One Thing From Doctors.” On KevinMD It has another title and the final paragraph was moved to the introduction.

    It is a satyrical narrative on what leads to physician burnout. Since we sometimes think in parallel, perhaps you may have interest in a guest post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.